Local

Well-loved southern seafood restaurant in Myrtle Beach, SC closes its doors. What we know

Mural of Yammassee native American tribe fishing the shoreline of Wither’s Swash painted on the side of Cackalacky Fish Company by local artist April Bensch. Cackalacky closed in mid-September 2024.
Mural of Yammassee native American tribe fishing the shoreline of Wither’s Swash painted on the side of Cackalacky Fish Company by local artist April Bensch. Cackalacky closed in mid-September 2024. jlee@thesunnews.com

A well-loved southern seafood restaurant and fish market in Myrtle Beach closed over the weekend, according to a Facebook post.

Cackalacky’s Fish Company at 400 S. Kings Highway closed for good on Sept. 15, employee Angela Green posted on Facebook.

“Today I went to work with a heavy and broken heart, sad trying to work and not want this night to end. Cackalacky Fish co. Is closing up. Tonight was our last night,” Green wrote in a post that was shared on social media.

The restaurant served fresh, fried and steamed seafood, including flounder, blue crab and oysters, reviews and pictures of the menu showed. Customers also found southern favorites like mac and cheese, hush puppies and collard greens.

Cackalacky Fish Co., owned by William Benfield. Wither’s Swash, Myrtle Beach, S.C. Aug. 24, 2022.
Cackalacky Fish Co., owned by William Benfield. Wither’s Swash, Myrtle Beach, S.C. Aug. 24, 2022. JASON LEE jlee@thesunnews.com

It’s unclear why the restaurant closed. Green did not return a request to a comment and The Sun News was unable to get in contact with owner William Benfield.

Benfield opened Cackalacky’s in 2021 after previously running the Berry’s Seafood Market in North Myrtle Beach, The Sun News reported.

It was previously rated as one of the best spots to get fried fish and hush puppies in the Myrtle Beach area by The Sun News.

Emalyn Muzzy
The Sun News
Emalyn Muzzy is the retail and leisure reporter for The Sun News. She started as a breaking news reporter in Myrtle Beach before switching to the business beat. She graduated from the University of Minnesota is 2022 with a degree in journalism and Spanish.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER