Myrtle Beach Sun News Logo

A ‘raw deal’ for America: High taxes, higher debt, no relief | Myrtle Beach Sun News

×
  • E-edition
  • Home
    • Customer Service
    • Subscribe
    • Activate Your Account
    • Account Support
    • Mobile Apps
    • Newsletters
    • The Sun News Store
    • FAQ
    • Cancel SunValues Delivery
    • Plan
    • All Tourist Info
    • Vacation Planner
    • Calendar
    • Where to Stay
    • Ask a Local
    • Festivals Guide
    • Best of the Area
    • Play
    • Nightlife
    • Golf
    • Shopping
    • Shows
    • Myrtle Beach Blog
    • Restaurants

  • Obituaries
    • All News
    • Local News
    • Crime/Courts
    • Business
    • State News
    • Nation/World
    • Weird News
    • More News
    • Politics
    • Myrtle Beach Bike Rallies
    • Submit A News Tip
    • Tourism News
    • Real Estate News
    • All Sports
    • High Schools
    • Coastal Carolina
    • Recreation
    • Golf
    • MB Pelicans
    • Auto Racing
    • More Sports
    • College Sports
    • NFL
    • MLB
    • MB Marathon
    • Toast Of The Coast
    • Green Reading Blog
    • The Roost Blog
    • All Opinion
    • Letters To The Editor
    • Submit A Letter
    • Editorial
    • Cartoons
    • Columns & Blogs
    • Bob Bestler
    • All Living
    • Coasting
    • Neighbors
    • Food
    • Best Of The Beach
    • Announcements
    • Religion
    • Travel
    • Pets
    • Home & Garden
    • All Entertainment
    • Kicks!
    • Best Of The Beach
    • Movies
    • Calendar
    • Contests
    • More Entertainment
    • Comics
    • Puzzles & Games
    • Horoscopes
    • Celebrities
    • Music
    • TV

  • Legals
  • Cars
  • Jobs
  • Moonlighting
  • Homes
  • Classifieds
  • Classified Ads

  • About Us
  • Mobile & Apps

Editorials

A ‘raw deal’ for America: High taxes, higher debt, no relief

    ORDER REPRINT →

September 12, 2012 02:46 PM

HILLSDALE, Mich.

The New Deal — Franklin Roosevelt’s program for getting the U.S. out of the Great Depression — failed miserably. Throughout the 1930s, unemployment remained mired in double digits. In May 1939, with Roosevelt’s second term almost at an end, unemployment had jumped again to more than 20 percent. In frustration, Henry Morgenthau, the president’s trusted secretary of treasury, blurted out, “We have tried spending money. We are spending more than we have ever spent before, and it does not work. … We have never made good on our promises. … I say after eight years of this administration we have just as much unemployment as when we started. … And an enormous debt to boot.”

Why did FDR’s lavish New Deal spending, contrary to predictions by Keynesian economists, produce so few jobs? Because every job he created with federal dollars had to be paid for out of taxes (or with debt). Tax dollars were simply taken from private citizens, who could have bought tires, neckties or cheese sandwiches, and given to politicians, who spent it on road building at best or increased federal salaries at worst. Jobs, however, are created by private investment, not by government redistribution.

The rising taxes during FDR’s presidency illustrated massive federal spending at work. In 1932, the year Roosevelt was elected, the top marginal tax rate was 25 percent. By 1935, FDR secured a tax hike on the rich to 79 percent. By 1945, the year he died, rich people paid 94 percent on all income over $200,000. Most other Americans had begun paying taxes as well, and at rates similar to the 25 percent rate for rich people back in 1932. How can we expect entrepreneurs to invest in new jobs when more than half of what they earn must be given to Uncle Sam?

SIGN UP

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The Sun News

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

Under both Presidents Hoover and Roosevelt, we saw tax rates rise and revenue fall. In 1929, for example, revenue from income taxes was almost $1.1 billion, but by 1935 it had been cut in half to $527 million. The national debt, however, skyrocketed from $17 billion to $29 billion during these years. By the end of FDR’s second term (1941), our national debt was almost $50 billion. We had chased capital out of the economy and enlarged our debt. The resulting class warfare was the essence of FDR’s New Deal, and the reason it created so few jobs.

That is a general overview of the New Deal. What about specific programs? For farmers, FDR launched the Agricultural Adjustment Act. It “solved” the problem of low prices by paying farmers not to grow crops on part of their land. Consumers, of course, had to pay higher prices for food, and taxes had to be increased to get cash to the farmers to pay them not to produce.

For silver miners, FDR signed the Silver Purchase Act, which sharply raised the price of silver. Harold Ickes, the secretary of interior, asked two penetrating questions: “Why should we be buying silver way above the market (price)? And if we do this for silver, why shouldn’t we buy other products for what the producers want instead of paying what they are worth?”

For welfare, FDR continued and expanded Hoover’s Emergency Relief and Construction Act of 1932. But under that act, as I describe in “New Deal or Raw Deal?” those states that were incompetent in managing their money could request and secure more federal funds than states that were frugal and cautious. For example, Illinois, which had greatly mismanaged its relief money, received $55,443,721, and Massachusetts, which was well-run, received zero federal funds. Thus, the residents of Massachusetts paid for their own state’s relief and, through federal taxes, for part of Illinois’ as well.

The best-known New Deal program was probably the Works Progress Administration. The hugely funded WPA supported the building of roads and other infrastructure throughout the nation. Good roads are a national gain, but FDR and Harry Hopkins, the head of the WPA, often distributed the WPA cash not where it was most needed, but where it would win the most votes. For example, V.G. Coplen, the Democratic county chairman of Indiana, said bluntly, “What I think will help is to change the WPA management from top to bottom. Put men in there who are … in favor of using these Democratic projects to make votes for the Democratic Party.” James Doherty, a New Hampshire Democrat, agreed: “It is my personal belief that to the victor belongs the spoils and that Democrats should be holding most of these (WPA) positions so that we might strengthen our fences for the 1940 election.”

Academics became fascinated with the way FDR used federal funds to win votes. C. Roger Dunn, a popular statistician of the 1930s, published the Dunn Survey on elections, and he estimated that each person on the WPA was worth four votes at the polls for FDR. Just in case, however, the president hired a pollster to detail where federal funds were going and give the Democrats bragging points about them — so that voters in each state could be reminded that keeping the Democrats in power would keep the federal faucet running. FDR’s tantalizing use of federal funds, and the promise of more to come, explains how he could keep winning elections even without an economic recovery. “The Democratic majorities in Congress are accounted for by the government billions,” the Chicago Tribune complained. “One doesn’t shoot Santa Claus,” observed Norman Thomas, head of the Socialist Party.

Reporter Thomas Stokes investigated the Democrats’ misuse of federal funds and called it “a grand political racket in which the taxpayer is the victim.” He won a Pulitzer Prize for his writing on the WPA, but was sad that New Dealers denounced him. Stokes concluded about the New Dealers, “They sought refuge in the seductive philosophy that the end justifies the means and, under this philosophy, they condoned the political organization of relief workers.”

When opponents of FDR pushed back at him, he expanded federal power to strike at them. For example, FDR was, according to his son Elliott, the first president to use the IRS for political purposes. He helped launch tax investigations of Andrew Mellon, the secretary of treasury under Coolidge, and Moses Annenberg, editor of the main Republican newspaper in Philadelphia. But when the IRS investigated then-congressman Lyndon Johnson of Texas, FDR called it off because Johnson, a key political ally, asked him to.

Roosevelt used the New Deal and the enlarged power of the executive branch to help him win four elections for president, and solidify the Democrats’ hold on Congress. Future Democratic presidents ever since FDR have studied his tactics for wisdom on how to win votes, how to gain political power, and how to increase federal control.

Contact Folsom, professor of history at Hillsdale College and co-author (with Anita Folsom) of “FDR Goes to War,” at bfolsom@hillsdale.edu.

  Comments  

Videos

A traditional Native American flute performance.

Charlotte welcomes the NBA All-Star game

View More Video

Trending Stories

He boarded bus for North Myrtle High, but never showed, cops say. Now a search is on

February 15, 2019 08:02 AM

Loris police investigating reported bank robbery

February 14, 2019 02:06 PM

Gang members sold drugs out of nearly every room in an Atlantic Beach complex, suit says

February 14, 2019 05:43 PM

3 calls, 6 hours: MB sees spike in overdose calls while county drug death numbers grow

February 14, 2019 08:38 AM

One person in critical condition after car goes into pond in Surfside area, officials say

February 14, 2019 06:25 AM

things to do

Read Next

Extortion claims and Horry County’s problem with transparency need to be solved — now

Editorials

Extortion claims and Horry County’s problem with transparency need to be solved — now

By The Myrtle Beach Sun News Editorial Board

    ORDER REPRINT →

January 04, 2019 11:00 AM

On the very day he was sworn in as Horry County Council chairman, Johnny Gardner denied any wrongdoing in the claims of extortion in a most unusual case under investigation by the S.C. Law Enforcement Division. The situation has plenty of political intrigue including a leaked, unsubstantiated report of an alleged — particular emphasis, if you will — crime, and elected and appointed public officials refusing to talk on the record.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The Sun News

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE EDITORIALS

Editorials

Voting should be easier than standing in long lines at polling places

November 09, 2018 10:43 AM
Chamber’s bare minimum reporting isn’t enough. City needs to demand more detail.

Editorials

Chamber’s bare minimum reporting isn’t enough. City needs to demand more detail.

September 07, 2018 08:29 AM
President Trump, we’re not ‘enemies of the people.’ End your war on our free press

Editorials

President Trump, we’re not ‘enemies of the people.’ End your war on our free press

August 15, 2018 06:06 PM

Editorials

Task force is a good step, but human trafficking is a problem we must quickly address

August 10, 2018 11:13 AM
International Drive project will seem easy by time we drive on Interstate 73

Editorials

International Drive project will seem easy by time we drive on Interstate 73

August 03, 2018 11:44 AM

Editorials

Horry County administration oversteps in directing elected coroner

June 29, 2018 12:17 PM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

Myrtle Beach Sun News App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
Advertising
  • Place a Classified
  • Advertise
  • Rates
  • Contests & Promotions
  • Local Deals
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story