Myrtle Beach Online - News, Sports & Entertainment from The Sun News
Myrtle Beach Online's Mug Shots Index Career Builder
Search for

Web Search powered by YAHOO!
News - Local

Thursday, Jul. 29, 2010

Ariz. law slapped down

Judge rules against immigration measure

- Los Angeles Times
email this story to a friend E-Mail print story Print 0 comments Reprint or license
Text Size:

tool name

close
tool goes here

PHOENIX -- A federal judge on Wednesday blocked the most controversial elements of Arizona's new immigration law, thrilling the law's opponents, dismaying its advocates and setting the stage for more legal battles in the future.

"We would have liked to have seen it all upheld, but a temporary injunction is not the end of it," said Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer, who signed the legislation in April.

"I look at this as a little bump in the road."

Similar stories:

  • Supreme Court to consider controversial Arizona immigration law

  • Parts of S.C. immigration law blocked by federal judge

  • Supreme Court’s stance could spur immigration laws nationwide

  • Many questions as court hears immigration case

  • Federal judge puts SC immigration lawsuit on hold

The governor said she was looking forward to getting started on the appeals process. "Jan Brewer is not a quitter," she said.

U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton halted implementation of the parts of the law that require police to determine the immigration status of people they stop and think are in the country illegally.

She also forbade the state from charging anyone with failure to possess immigration documents, a crime under the new law.

In her 36-page decision, Bolton wrote that the measure would have hamstrung the federal government's efforts to enforce immigration law.

"The federal government's ability to enforce its policies and achieve its objectives will be undermined by the state's enforcement of statutes that interfere with federal law," she wrote.

The law's supporters, who contended it was needed to stop illegal immigrants from coming to Arizona, vowed a swift appeal.

Brewer, speaking with reporters as she left the University of Arizona technology park, said she believes the law is constitutional.

Brewer also said, as she has repeatedly in the past, that the law was an attempt to protect the state.

"I wish that the federal government would step up and do their job so we could all be safe and secure in the state of Arizona," she said.

Immigrant-rights groups were ebullient.

"It means justice will truly prevail," said Lydia Guzman, president of Somos America, or We Are America.

Phoenix Vice Mayor Michael Nowakowski, an opponent of the measure, told reporters outside the courthouse that the ruling was "a victory for individuals who say the federal law is the federal law."

Bolton's ruling found that the Obama administration was likely to prevail at trial in proving that the provisions requiring police to determine immigration status and immigrants to carry documents, along with two other provisions of the sweeping law, were an unconstitutional attempt by Arizona to regulate immigration.

Arizona is expected to immediately appeal the decision.

Polls have shown that Arizonans overwhelmingly support the anti-illegal immigration law, known as SB 1070.

Subscribe to The Sun News Print Edition
The Sun News allows readers to comment on stories as a privilege; the views expressed in story comments are not those of the Sun News or its staff. Readers are required to adhere to all commenting policies, and must avoid commenting behavior such as personal attacks, libelous posts or inappropriate remarks. Users in violation of The Sun News' commenting policies can have their comments blocked, removed, and/or ultimately see their account banned from the site. Some comments may be reprinted in the newspaper. Registered user names will be posted with comments.
The Sun News Terms & Conditions and Commenting Policies can be reviewed here.
   Connect with Us:
Connect with The Sun News on Twitter
Connect with The Sun News on Facebook
Sign up for The Sun News' newsletters, breaking and local news straight to your email inbox
Get up to the minute news from The Sun News Text Alerts.
Get late-breaking Weather News from The Sun News' Weather Text Alerts
Get The Sun News Newspaper online everyday, just as it appears in print
Subscribe too our RSS feeds
Twitter Facebook News
Letters
Text
Alerts
Weather Alerts Daily
E -Edition
RSS
 
Events Calendar:
Career Builder Quick Job Search
Quick Job Search
Top Jobs